$99 bucks for 30 blogs sounds pretty good, right?
As a medical marketing agency, we see it every day now: a new tool is promising you amazing AI-generated content for a tiny fraction of the cost. The allure of pressing a button and generating daily blog posts using an AI content platform at a low cost is tempting.
We 100% get it.
But we’re going to rip the bandaid off, you’re getting what you pay for here. We’re not saying creating TONS of content using AI is bad. We actually like that part in some cases. But there is a massive difference between “writing a blog” and “building an SEO asset” and the data proves it.
RUNNER’s First Encounter With Unedited AI-Generated Content
*This Actually Happened*
“Yeah, I don’t need you to write blog content or do SEO for me. I have a platform that makes 30 blogs a month for me for $99 bucks. It even publishes them right on my website. I don’t have to do anything.” That’s what a recent brand told RUNNER Agency. And honestly, our first thought was “wow, that’s a killer deal.” It’s insane really. We figured the actual quality of the blogs is probably not premier professional copywriting with high SEO value, but we thought it would at least be decent, and maybe we could just optimize it a bit for them.
But when we looked at the blogs, our stomachs dropped.
It wasn’t the severe keyword cannibalization, the awkward phrasing, or the odd keyword usage. It wasn’t the redundant copywriting, or clear lack of value resulting in just words on a page without actually saying anything. It wasn’t even the multiple blog posts covering the exact same topic in a single month.
At RUNNER Agency, we exclusively specialise in medical marketing, it’s what we’re known for. So when we took a look at the AI-generated and posted blogs this medical brand was putting out for the world to see…..the world saw a septic tank.
On a medical website, AI used a septic tank as the featured image across multiple blogs. A SEPTIC TANK.
It was at that moment, we understood why it was $99.
The “Peak and Plummet” of AI Written Content
To truly understand if AI content is good or bad for SEO, we can look to a recent experiment by Search Engine Land and SE Ranking. This 16-month study involved creating 20 brand-new domains across various niches and publishing 2,000 AI-generated articles (100 per site) with no human intervention, to see how these posts perform in search results.
Many of these sites saw a quick spike in indexing and traffic in the first 90 days with “71% of new AI-generated pages indexed within the first 36 days,” according to Search Engine Land. With straightforward structure and targeting low-competition keywords, early data implies AI-generated could content be promising.
But by months 3–6, their performance plummeted and never recovered, with little to no visibility for these AI-generated web pages whatsoever. Over a year later, it was clear that visibility for these AI-generated blog posts had stagnated with “no site show[ing] meaningful recovery.”
So what does this actually mean for brands? AI-generated content has a shelf life.
Outside of SEO best practices, there are 2 key things AI-generated content for SEO just can’t do (yet):
- Google’s algorithms are always getting better at identifying content that is simply re-summarizing existing web data (which is exactly what AI does). Without unique insights, original data, or “EEAT” (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trust), the content loses its visibility quickly.
- Unedited AI content can sometimes feel a bit “flat” to readers, which hurts the trust you’re trying to build with your audience, plus create poor user experiences that negatively impact your SEO signals.
The main takeaway here is that the primary danger of the “AI-only” strategy is that its failure isn’t immediate, it’s around the 3 month mark. And when you remember that SEO is a long-term play it’s clear that site content 100% written by AI is not a high-value tactic for your overall marketing strategy.
AI-Generated Content Risk to Brand Trust
In any industry, any niche, brand trust is an integral part of success. And it’s a pretty simple concept. Consumers buy from brands they trust. Period. Building brand trust takes time, effort, and empathy. Every interaction with your audience is an opportunity to build trust, or break it.
According to a 3,000 person study by Raptive about the impression of AI-generated content:
- 48% found it to be less trustworthy
- 57% found it to be less authentic
- 60% found it to be less emotionally connecting.
In medical marketing, less emotion, authenticity and trust, creates major roadblocks for patient acquisition.
Medical SEO Requires More Than Just AI-Generated Content
Google uses search quality guidelines to assess the relevance and quality of search results. For most industries, the focus is on the E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, and Trustworthiness) framework. Basically, this means Google wants to see content that demonstrates these 4 elements.
In the medical field, Google layers on a’ stricter’ framework known as YMYL (Your Money or Your Life). Because medical content can impact someone’s health, the Google algorithm holds medical brands to a higher standard compared to other industries.
Unmonitored AI-generated content fails E-E-A-T and YMYL for 3 main reasons:
- No Experience: AI is a text aggregator. AI can only scrape what’s already online, It cannot inject the authenticity or experience because it has none.
- Medical Inaccuracies: AI can “hallucinate” and make things up. It can create ‘facts’ that sound confident but are clinically wrong. In medical marketing, a single inaccuracy can destroy your brand trust and lead to potential liability.
- No Information Gain: Google rewards unique content. AI simply reshuffles what is already available on the internet. If your blog content doesn’t offer anything new, why would Google rank it above the thousands of other articles AI used to write it in the first place?
SEO and AI Want Quality Over Quantity, Google Says So
At RUNNER Agency, we believe that SEO-optimized content and AI-optimized content is an investment, not a commodity, because …well…Google said so, and we see the proof in the data in studies like Search Engine Land’s AI experiment and our very own clients. 90 days of performance for AI-generated content is not going to move a brand forward in its long term goals.
At a high level, there are 2 organic search places medical brands want to appear, Google search results and AI mentions. To do this medical marketers look at SEO tactics and AI visibility tactics when building out an organic strategy. We’ve long said that because LLMs look at websites to generate their results and mentions, SEO best practices (including local SEO) still matter significantly in the AI world. Recently, Google released a guide backing this up.
The Optimizing your website for generative AI features on Google Search guide by Google clearly states that SEO is still relevant, and even doubles down on the notion that cutting corners and ‘hacks’ won’t lead to long term success. It’s still all about creating quality, unique content that people actually want to read; that’s actually helpful and relevant. The guide’s recap says it best:
E-E-A-T and YMYL are still the frameworks Google is using to gauge the value of your content when determining if it wants to serve it up in search results or AI results. Is your AI-generated content tool doing its job? Or is it posting blogs for the sake of posting blogs?
Is AI-Generated Content Good for SEO and AEO?
If you are looking for a quick, temporary spike in visibility, AI-generated content might get you there. But if you are looking to build a sustainable, authoritative digital presence that attracts and converts patients for years to come, AI-generated content is proving to be a risky choice at best.
At RUNNER Agency, we view AI as a tool. It’s not in the driver seat and when it comes to content generation, the data in the studies and our experience in creating and measuring the performance of 100+ new blogs every month for our client base tells us that a human touch in healthcare SEO is an absolute must for growth-minded medical practices.
Don’t let a “cheap” strategy ruin your search engine and AI engine performance. Your practice deserves content that reflects the high level of care you provide.
Is your current content strategy built for a 3-month spike or 3 years of growth? Let’s talk about building a high-quality, SEO-driven content plan for your practice.


